"Warm cascades of acoustic guitars, piano and brooding vocals are threaded along on bare wisps of beats. These textured, economical arrangements are a complete about-face from those on Take Back, yet they create a melancholy mood piece that fulfills the promise of Creeper's earliest songs. It's Creeper Lagoon's most satisfying offering yet, and if it's any indication of what's to come, the future will indeed be worth remembering."

-Michael Ansaldo, Rolling Stone

"Creeper brings out more of the introverted, nocturnal melodies that's made it a band that all the college kids won't shut up about in 1999. Get ready for more college-kid babbling, as Remember the Future is as strong of a release as anything to ever crawl out of the depths of the Lagoon."

-aversion.com